Back to blog frontpage

Your website does not meet accessibility (WCAG) criteria - our developers advise whether to fix the current website or create an entirely new website

Sigrid Viikmaa

Compliance with WCAG (Web Content Accessibility Guidelines) criteria is crucial to creating software solutions. Read more about how accessibility benefits everyone in our previous blog.

According to our accessibility specialist Mari-Ell Mets, from 2019, the obligation to ensure accessibility established by the European Union directive applies to the public sector, which essentially means that websites and mobile applications must meet the AA level of the WCAG 2.1 standard.

From 2025, this obligation will also apply to certain areas of the private sector. You can find a detailed overview of the requirements in the Accessibility Act. Ensuring accessibility is based on four principles: perceptibility, functionality, comprehensibility and reliability, which are divided into criteria, and if fulfilled, a website can achieve the required level (AA). Ensuring accessibility is generally time-consuming, and we recommend to start preparing for the transition now.

Suppose your website does not yet meet the AA level of the WCAG 2.1 standard. In that case, you have two options:

  1. develop an entirely new website that immediately meets the accessibility criteria or
  2. update the existing one (front-end facelift).

In this article, our developers Mairo Aljaste and Sander Rautam and specialists help you decide which solution is the best for you.

How to start the development process?

It is necessary to decide with the development partner whether it is reasonable to create a new website or adapt the old one to meet the WCAG criteria.

If you want a new website, you must first have the designers prepare a design that meets the UX/UI and WCAG requirements. However, choosing a facelift to bring your existing page into compliance with WCAG requirements, we recommend starting with an audit to identify problematic areas on your website. We recommend analyzing the audit results with the developers to assess your website's WCAG level at the moment and what can and cannot be improved.

There are different levels of WCAG guidelines, and you definitely don't have to do everything at once. In cooperation with the development partner, you can establish the order of priorities and also decide which accessibility tools should be focused on (screen readers, browsers, operating systems, etc.).

Option 1: Improving existing web accessibility

In such a scenario, the website has already complied with accessibility standards to some extent, and you want to supplement or improve the existing solution. This step considers the users and is a much better choice than staying at the previous level. However, this option can be challenging in terms of development and cost. Let's talk more about the pros and cons.